There is a Such Thing as Bad Music

Image result for autotune machine

With every generation comes the older generations complaining about the kids of today. The way they dress, the way they are addicted to technology, their music. “Today’s music isn’t like when I was a kid,” you will hear ad nauseam. The truth is there has always been music that lacked in quality compared to the best music. There was always music that preached a harmful message or that lacked substance. But, the question remains whether or not the music of today has actually dipped in quality and whether or not it has a legitimate affect on society. Is there actually a such thing as bad music or is music truly subjective to each individual? And when people are made aware of better, more healthier musical options do people prefer them?

I was inspired to consider this for a number of reasons. One of these reasons was my favorite all time music quote that was made by an artist that I greatly respect. That quote comes from Jason Isbell and reads, “I don’t believe all music is good. I believe some music is bad for people to listen to. I think it makes their tastes worse. I think it makes their lives worse. I think it makes them worse people. Some things you have to refuse.” Isbell believes that not only is not all music good but, the bad music actually plays a negative role in peoples lives.

Another inspiration for this post was Trigger over at Saving Country Music. I am sure if you are reading this you have been over to his site (if not you should check it out). The aforementioned post which was made in September discussed why mainstream country music listeners chose to listen to the shitty pop music played on country radio. Trigger’s theory which I agreed with was that the consumers are just not aware of the better music that exists outside of country radio. I will use myself as an example because, I think this illustrates the idea well. When I first began listening to country music in middle school I had no idea of anything that existed outside of country radio. What I did know was that I liked the country music that I knew better than any other genre of music. I also knew that for some reason my tastes were always in favor of traditional leaning artists like Josh Turner and at the time Easton Corbin.

What actually allowed me to begin to discover better music and evolve as a music listener was when I began reading independent country music blogs. I always had an interest in reading music reviews so, when I started reading reviews of bands I had never heard of, I gave them a try. And you know what? My taste in music, not just country music changed dramatically. The bar was no longer Florida Georgia Line and Luke Bryan, it was The Turnpike Troubadours and Sturgill Simpson. These healthier options changed the way that I think and not just about music. I learned things from listening to this better music and I believe that it has made me a better more rounded individual.

The last thing that inspired me to do this post was not just country music but, pop music. Have you looked at the music charts recently and seen the despicable filth that is the most played music not just in America but the world? One of them is the disgraceful “Side to Side,” by Arianna Grande. For those of you not familiar, it is a song about being f***ed so hard that she can’t walk straight. Another song that is one of the most played in the country is the non offensive but stupid “Cake by the Ocean.” There is no message here whatsoever, it is just pure filler.

In regards to the quality of the country music charts I won’t even discuss whether the music is country or not. For the purpose of this post let me only look at the substance of the music that has found success lately. Three songs that are currently in the top 30 of the Mediabase chart are “Think a Little Less,” “Seein’ Red” and “If The Boot Fits.” Most likely, all of these songs will at some point grace the top of the charts despite all being terrible songs. “Think a little Less” is a song about a guy telling a girl not to think about why she shouldn’t hook up with him, just do it. The girls friends will judge her for hooking up with this loser but, thankfully Michael Ray has a solution which is to lie to them to save herself the embarrassment. Sounds like a swell guy. “Seein’ Red” is honestly about nothing. And “If The Boot Fits” is a terrible bro country song which actually has the line “You could be the one I could get lucky with.” Charming Granger.

So the question is, with all these terrible songs receiving regular airplay and being shoved down the throats of the ignorant masses, does it matter? Does it matter that the music played on the radio isn’t country or that the substance has all but disappeared? I recently read an article written by Tom Barnes of Music Mic called How the Music Industry is Brainwashing You to Like Bad Pop Songs,  which was written two years ago that asks this very question in regards to pop music. Barnes’ position in this article is that the music industry is essentially brainwashing people to like bad songs. The theory is, the more that our brains hear the same songs, the more we begin to like them even if we didn’t like them at first. This is because the reward centers of the brain are more active when we hear songs that we have heard before. The music industry knows this and therefore manipulates the consumers into liking songs and artists that they only like due to repeated exposure changing their opinion of the music.

The music of the time has a clear affect on the younger, more impressionable generation of listeners. Many people are quick to blame rap music for the ills of society but, it’s not just rap music. It is practically every genre of music that is played on the radio. Every genre has “artists” and labels whose only goal is to make the most money possible with complete indifference towards the art or what the consequences will be of releasing that music. Whether it is “Blurred Lines” which sends the message that rape is okay or whether it is a song that normalizes meth use like “Fix” does, these songs have dangerous consequences for society especially with those sensitive subject matters.

When people are given healthier options do they actually chose them? The answer appears to be an emphatic yes especially in recent years. Consider the success that independent artists have had in recent years despite virtually no help from country radio. Just some of the albums in the last couple of years to have massive success without radio are, The Underdog, Holding All The Roses, Gotta Be Me, Midwestern Farmer’s Daughter, A Sailor’s Guide to Earth and I could go on and on with examples like these. These are terrific albums of substance that have found success because, people are sick and tired of the horrible music being played on country radio. To show how out of touch country radio is consider this. Girl Problems by Chris Lane actually sold less albums in it’s first week than I’m Not The Devil by Cody Jinks. Chris Lane, the American Idol reject  had a #1 song in the meth infused “Fix” meanwhile Cody Jinks is lucky to get airplay on the secondary chart. This should be seen as a loud message being sent to country radio that is finally beginning to gain traction.

The lifeless, auto-tuned, substance-less music is making people dumber. The music is making their lives worse and must be resisted. There is no art to much of the music being pedaled to radio. The industry has become overly corporate and basic norms and expectations, like in politics have gone right out the window. There is hope though. As I mentioned before, independent artists are putting out some of the best music across all genres and are being noticed more than ever before. Artists like Margo Price, Sturgill Simpson and Cody Jinks are breaking through and carving out a place for quality music. Late night shows are allowing them to perform and showcase their talents and the world is taking notice. The last refuge for the Florida Georgia Lines and Dustin Lynch’s of the world is the radio. Unfortunately for them, they are killing it.




  1. Definitely a lot to dissect here, let me first off say that I enjoy the piece overall and like that you point to other articles to help frame your point. Now, what I’m about to say is solely my opinion, and I’m not trying to say MY line of thinking is right, just stating it.

    Anyway, I honestly don’t believe in taste in music. Good, bad…whatever, I believe that’s completely individualistic. I’m not saying that I like songs such as “Seein’ Red”, or “If The Boot Fits”, but that’s me. I don’t think I can say they aren’t good because to someone else, they might be.

    Now, as long as someone can back up WHY they like something with enough reasons, I can totally respect that. Fpr example, if you liked the guitar work on “Seein’ Red”, fine. Now, if you’re just supporting an artist just because or like everything they do because of who they are, I can’t respect that. Again though, that’s just what I think.

    Now, I like the point about music actually causing harmful effects, and the article you brought up was interesting. Hell, we’ve seen enough reports of country concerts turning into giant clusterf*cks, and the reason why was probably songs that promoted partying, a.k.a bro-country. I can definitely agree with that.

    I also think it’s very important to introduce people to music beyond the radio. At this point, if ALL you know is the radio, you’re probably not interested enough in music to really care all that much, but for those who are beginning to explore, have at it. Now, I think it’s important to point out that just because someone hears Sturgill or Turnpike and decides it isn’t for them doesn’t mean they’re wrong. Like I said, I think taste and quality is completely subjective, and if someone tries out the independent side and decides they like pop – country better, hey more power to you. At least you tried it out.

    I apologize if I rambled on, I might make another comment tomorrow when I’m typing from somewhere other than my phone lol. Great piece though!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. In regards to the bad music I was more trying to get at the idea that some music has harmful effects on society. Your point about the country concerts is a great one. People hear all these bro country songs about binge drinking and they go to these concerts and do just that. Also, good music can make you think critically, and can actually influence especially younger people. When they hear songs even outside of country music that degrade women, encourage drug use and violence that is making them worse people and will make their lives worse. I don’t think “If the Boot Fits” is making peoples lives worse necessarily but, it certainly isn’t improving their lives or their brains. If people don’t like certain artist that are deemed great artists that’s fine in fact, there’s plenty of all time great songs that I just don’t connect with or don’t enjoy so I get it. Btw go on and ramble haha I’m interested to see what people think of this piece.


      1. I know I said I’d comment tomorrow but I will say this – while I think taste is completely subjective and individualistic, I do think that’s why I made my blog and why I think blogs are so important. I’ve got my thoughts and I share them because I’m passionate about country music and because I care. Never trying to say anyone has to agree with me, just giving people food for thought for what it’s worth. I also care about what other people have to say, that’s why I support anyone who makes their blog to give their honest opinions. I’m not a fan of the concept of “the critical consensus”, but it’s always cool to see what other people are into. I’m not sure if this has anything to do with the piece at this point, I think it did at one point. Yeah, I better comment tomorrow lol.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Yeah, it relates. That’s really a big part of the piece whether or not all music is subjective to the individual or if there is some music that is not only bad but harmful. I think we disagree a little bit on that idea but we both acknowledge the harmful effects some music clearly has.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s